Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room

The easiest 5 stars to give because this was the best pizza I’ve ever had! The Bianca pizza, the house salad, the bacon candy- get them all if you can because I can’t even type this review without my mouth watering because they were so, so good. The pizza crust was perfectly cooked, which is an impressive feat as sometimes brick oven pizza can get too toasty very quickly, and the toppings for the Bianca pizza were generous but also not in a way that weighed the pizza down or overpowered the crust’s quality. The house salad is an excellent combination of flavors and well worth getting. The bacon candy is cooked to a good chewiness without sliminess in the more fatty sections with the lightest sugary coating that compliments it so well. The service was great, especially with how packed the restaurant was, and our server chatted about the show we were seeing that evening. Although there were people waiting for tables, we didn’t feel rushed by the staff at all (though we tried to be speedy for the sake of other guests). A few logistical notes: They do not accept reservations, so arrive early, especially on nights when there are shows scheduled. They charge a 3% convenience fee for cards, so plan on bringing some cash if you want to save. This is a terrific option for the dinner part of dinner and a show, or just a quality meal for the sake of eating out. I would highly recommend!

A great place to try! This was my Husband and I’s second visit to Proper and we brought our family who had never been there before. The espresso martinis (add baileys if you like a creamer espresso martini) are some of the best I’ve ever had! The fried brussel sprouts are amazing and you really can’t go wrong with any pizza you order. The dough is delicious and they always cook it to perfection! A must stop if you’re in the area!