auto mechanic in Columbus, OH

Ranked by trust — balancing rating quality with review depth

20 businesses found

Sort by:

Most Trusted ranks by Smart Score — a formula that balances star rating with review volume so that a business with 4.7★ across 2,000 reviews outranks one with 4.9★ across 5 reviews.

Rising Stars9 businesses with strong ratings and under 300 reviews

One Call Auto Mechanic

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.91,580 reviewsClosed

6066 Busch Blvd, Columbus, OH 43229, USA

·Strong 4.9★ rating across 1,580 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·High review volume signals an established track record.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Weber Road Auto Service

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.91,240 reviewsClosed

1100 E Weber Rd, Columbus, OH 43211, USA

·Strong 4.9★ rating across 1,240 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·High review volume signals an established track record.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Streamline Auto

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.9648 reviewsClosed

3040 Cleveland Ave, Columbus, OH 43224, USA

·Strong 4.9★ rating across 648 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·High review volume signals an established track record.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

The JAM Shop Auto Repair

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

5.0211 reviewsClosed

6491 Nicholas Dr, Columbus, OH 43235, USA

·Strong 5.0★ rating across 211 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.
·Reviews are highly consistent — customers get a reliable experience.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Buckeye Complete Auto Care

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.71,198 reviewsClosed

3701 Karl Rd, Columbus, OH 43224, USA

·Strong 4.7★ rating across 1,198 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·High review volume signals an established track record.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Urban Auto Repairs

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.8362 reviewsClosed

1660 Peabody Ave, Columbus, OH 43223, USA

·Strong 4.8★ rating across 362 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.
·Reviews are highly consistent — customers get a reliable experience.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Mike's Foreign Car Service

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.8236 reviewsClosed

1379 River St, Columbus, OH 43222, USA

·Strong 4.8★ rating across 236 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.
·Reviews are highly consistent — customers get a reliable experience.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Luke's Auto Repair - Grandview

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.7320 reviewsClosed

1107 Dublin Rd, Columbus, OH 43215, USA

·Strong 4.7★ rating across 320 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.
·Reviews are highly consistent — customers get a reliable experience.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

All Hours Automotive Repair

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.8151 reviewsClosed

2386 Wood Ave, Columbus, OH 43221, USA

·Strong 4.8★ rating across 151 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.
·Reviews are highly consistent — customers get a reliable experience.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Clintonville Automotive Repair Service

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.6387 reviewsClosed

585 Oakland Park Ave, Columbus, OH 43214, USA

·Solid 4.6★ rating with a meaningful review sample of 387.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.
·Reviews are highly consistent — customers get a reliable experience.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Avenue Auto Repair

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.7169 reviewsClosed

2172 E Livingston Ave, Columbus, OH 43209, USA

·Strong 4.7★ rating across 169 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.
·Reviews are highly consistent — customers get a reliable experience.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Alternative Auto Care

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.5482 reviewsClosed

136 W 5th Ave, Columbus, OH 43201, USA

·Solid 4.5★ rating with a meaningful review sample of 482.
·High review volume signals an established track record.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Luke's Auto

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.82,154 reviewsClosed

5393 Sinclair Rd, Columbus, OH 43229, USA

·Strong 4.8★ rating across 2,154 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·High review volume signals an established track record.
·Mixed recent ratings — the customer experience appears inconsistent.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Prime Auto Repairs

Trusted

★★★★★

4.733 reviewsOpen now

1138 E Hudson St, Columbus, OH 43211, USA

·Solid 4.7★ rating with a meaningful review sample of 33.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.
·Reviews are highly consistent — customers get a reliable experience.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Tom and Jerry's Auto Service

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.7441 reviewsClosed

1701 Kenny Rd, Columbus, OH 43212, USA

·Strong 4.7★ rating across 441 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·High review volume signals an established track record.
·Mixed recent ratings — the customer experience appears inconsistent.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Luke's Auto Repair - Upper Arlington

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.8225 reviewsClosed

4818 Reed Rd, Columbus, OH 43220, USA

·Strong 4.8★ rating across 225 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·Mixed recent ratings — the customer experience appears inconsistent.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Budget Auto Fix

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.7330 reviewsClosed

2608 Sullivant Ave, Columbus, OH 43204, USA

·Strong 4.7★ rating across 330 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·Mixed recent ratings — the customer experience appears inconsistent.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Valentino's Car Care

Trusted

★★★★★

4.8130 reviewsClosed

1766 W 5th Ave, Columbus, OH 43212, USA

·Strong 4.8★ rating across 130 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·Mixed recent ratings — the customer experience appears inconsistent.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Ohio Autocare

Trusted

★★★★★

4.845 reviewsClosed

2740 Old Courtright Rd, Columbus, OH 43232, USA

·Strong 4.8★ rating across 45 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·Mixed recent ratings — the customer experience appears inconsistent.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Harolds Automotive

Trusted

★★★★★

4.884 reviewsClosed

840 Mansfield Ave, Columbus, OH 43219, USA

·Strong 4.8★ rating across 84 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·Recent negative sentiment lowered the score — check the latest reviews.
·Mixed recent ratings — the customer experience appears inconsistent.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Rankings are based on public review signals only. No paid placements.

Designed to reduce bad experiences and help you choose with confidence.