general contractor in Columbus, OH

Ranked by trust — balancing rating quality with review depth

16 businesses found

Sort by:

Most Trusted ranks by Smart Score — a formula that balances star rating with review volume so that a business with 4.7★ across 2,000 reviews outranks one with 4.9★ across 5 reviews.

Rising Stars12 businesses with strong ratings and under 300 reviews

Rick Wheeler LLC

Trusted

★★★★★

5.072 reviewsClosed

4555 Groves Rd Suite 29, Columbus, OH 43232, USA

·Strong 5.0★ rating across 72 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.
·Reviews are highly consistent — customers get a reliable experience.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Nova Design Build

Trusted

★★★★★

5.062 reviewsClosed

3966 Brown Park Dr SUITE H, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA

·Strong 5.0★ rating across 62 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.
·Reviews are highly consistent — customers get a reliable experience.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Steller Construction

Trusted

★★★★★

5.049 reviewsClosed

400 Lazelle Rd #5, Columbus, OH 43240, USA

·Strong 5.0★ rating across 49 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.
·Reviews are highly consistent — customers get a reliable experience.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Wingler Construction & Remodeling

Trusted

★★★★★

4.881 reviewsClosed

771 S Hamilton Rd, Columbus, OH 43213, USA

·Strong 4.8★ rating across 81 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.
·Reviews are highly consistent — customers get a reliable experience.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Nicholson Builders

Trusted

★★★★★

4.877 reviewsClosed

6525 Busch Blvd, Columbus, OH 43229, USA

·Strong 4.8★ rating across 77 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.
·Reviews are highly consistent — customers get a reliable experience.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Columbus Handyman

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.6247 reviewsClosed

3757 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214, USA

·Solid 4.6★ rating with a meaningful review sample of 247.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.
·Reviews are highly consistent — customers get a reliable experience.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Combat Contracting

Trusted

★★★★★

4.862 reviewsOpen now

4694 Cemetery Rd, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA

·Strong 4.8★ rating across 62 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.
·Reviews are highly consistent — customers get a reliable experience.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

J.S. Brown & Co.

Trusted

★★★★★

4.849 reviewsClosed

1522 Hess St, Columbus, OH 43212, USA

·Strong 4.8★ rating across 49 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.
·Reviews are highly consistent — customers get a reliable experience.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Capital City Construction & Remodeling

Trusted

★★★★★

5.022 reviewsClosed

8720 Orion Pl 124 C, Columbus, OH 43240, USA

·Strong 5.0★ rating across 22 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.
·Reviews are highly consistent — customers get a reliable experience.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Pat Scales Remodeling & Home Renovation

Trusted

★★★★★

4.748 reviewsClosed

2339 W Dublin-Granville Rd, Columbus, OH 43235, USA

·Solid 4.7★ rating with a meaningful review sample of 48.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.
·Reviews are highly consistent — customers get a reliable experience.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Dave Fox

Trusted

★★★★★

4.483 reviewsClosed

3505 W Dublin-Granville Rd, Columbus, OH 43235, USA

·Solid 4.4★ rating with a meaningful review sample of 83.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.
·Reviews are highly consistent — customers get a reliable experience.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

True North Builders LLC

Trusted

★★★★★

5.010 reviewsClosed

PO 16291, 850 Twin Rivers Dr, Columbus, OH 43215, USA

·Solid 5.0★ rating with a meaningful review sample of 10.
·Review volume is below competitors — more reviews would sharpen the signal.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Lutton Construction

Trusted

★★★★★

4.936 reviewsOpen now

971 Old Henderson Rd, Columbus, OH 43220, USA

·Strong 4.9★ rating across 36 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·Mixed recent ratings — the customer experience appears inconsistent.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Old 2 New LLC Columbus General Contractor/ Builder / Remodeling

Trusted

★★★★★

4.525 reviewsClosed

3264 Fisher Rd, Columbus, OH 43204, USA

·Solid 4.5★ rating with a meaningful review sample of 25.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.
·Reviews are highly consistent — customers get a reliable experience.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Compton Construction

Trusted

★★★★★

5.08 reviewsClosed

691 Parsons Ave, Columbus, OH 43206, USA

·Solid 5.0★ rating with a meaningful review sample of 8.
·Review volume is below competitors — more reviews would sharpen the signal.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Construction One Inc

Trusted

★★★★★

4.317 reviewsClosed

101 E Town St #401, Columbus, OH 43215, USA

·Solid 4.3★ rating with a meaningful review sample of 17.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.
·Reviews are highly consistent — customers get a reliable experience.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

Rankings are based on public review signals only. No paid placements.

Designed to reduce bad experiences and help you choose with confidence.