restaurant in Indianapolis, IN

Ranked by trust — balancing rating quality with review depth

20 businesses found

Sort by:

Most Trusted ranks by Smart Score — a formula that balances star rating with review volume so that a business with 4.7★ across 2,000 reviews outranks one with 4.9★ across 5 reviews.

Showing restaurant in Indianapolis, IN

Rising Stars1 business with strong ratings and under 300 reviews

Salt on Mass

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.82,598 reviews$$$$Closed

505 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA

·Strong 4.8★ rating across 2,598 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·High review volume signals an established track record.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

→Stable

Dean's Steak & Seafood Indianapolis

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.9518 reviewsClosed

10 S West St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA

·Strong 4.9★ rating across 518 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·High review volume signals an established track record.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

→Stable

Harry & Izzy's

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.74,417 reviews$$$$Closed

153 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46225, USA

·Strong 4.7★ rating across 4,417 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·High review volume signals an established track record.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

→Stable

Livery

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.72,681 reviews$$$$Closed

720 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46202, USA

·Strong 4.7★ rating across 2,681 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·High review volume signals an established track record.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

→Stable

Conner's Kitchen + Bar

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.76,500 reviews$$$$Closed

350 W Maryland St, Indianapolis, IN 46225, USA

·Strong 4.7★ rating across 6,500 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·High review volume signals an established track record.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

→Stable

The Fountain Room

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.71,891 reviews$$$$Closed

830 Massachusetts Ave Suite 1480, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA

·Strong 4.7★ rating across 1,891 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·High review volume signals an established track record.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

→Stable

St. Elmo Steak House

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.66,827 reviews$$$$Closed

127 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46225, USA

·Solid 4.6★ rating with a meaningful review sample of 6,827.
·High review volume signals an established track record.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

→Stable

Commission Row

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.7268 reviewsClosed

110 S Delaware St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA

·Strong 4.7★ rating across 268 reviews — consistent quality at scale.
·Recent reviews are trending strongly positive.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

→Stable

Yard House

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.54,677 reviews$$$$Closed

15 W Maryland St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA

·Solid 4.5★ rating with a meaningful review sample of 4,677.
·High review volume signals an established track record.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

→Stable

Gather 22

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.6613 reviews$$$$Closed

22 E 22nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46202, USA

·Solid 4.6★ rating with a meaningful review sample of 613.
·High review volume signals an established track record.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

→Stable

The Eagle Mass Ave

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.55,029 reviews$$$$Closed

310 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA

·Solid 4.5★ rating with a meaningful review sample of 5,029.
·High review volume signals an established track record.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

→Stable

Slippery Noodle Inn

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.53,844 reviews$$$$Open now

372 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46225, USA

·Solid 4.5★ rating with a meaningful review sample of 3,844.
·High review volume signals an established track record.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

→Stable

Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.51,347 reviews$$$$Open now

65 E Pearl St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA

·Solid 4.5★ rating with a meaningful review sample of 1,347.
·High review volume signals an established track record.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

→Stable

Petra Cafe

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.5859 reviews$$$$Open now

610 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA

·Solid 4.5★ rating with a meaningful review sample of 859.
·High review volume signals an established track record.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

→Stable

The Oakmont

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.5871 reviews$$$$Open now

323 N Delaware St Suite B, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA

·Solid 4.5★ rating with a meaningful review sample of 871.
·High review volume signals an established track record.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

→Stable

Bocca

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.6289 reviews$$$$Closed

122 E 22nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46202, USA

·Solid 4.6★ rating with a meaningful review sample of 289.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

→Stable

Ball & Biscuit

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.5698 reviews$$$$Open now

331 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA

·Solid 4.5★ rating with a meaningful review sample of 698.
·High review volume signals an established track record.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

→Stable

High Velocity

Trusted

★★★★★

4.41,819 reviews$$$$Open now

10 S West St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA

·Solid 4.4★ rating with a meaningful review sample of 1,819.
·High review volume signals an established track record.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

→Stable

Vicino

Highly Trusted

★★★★★

4.5372 reviews$$$$Closed

350 Massachusetts Ave Suite 150, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA

·Solid 4.5★ rating with a meaningful review sample of 372.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

→Stable

The Social View

Trusted

★★★★★

4.3191 reviewsClosed

361 Indiana Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA

·Solid 4.3★ rating with a meaningful review sample of 191.

View on Maps ↗·Full trust analysis →

Review Rank

→Stable

Rankings are based on public review signals only. No paid placements.

Designed to reduce bad experiences and help you choose with confidence.